Some History Lessons

Back to my 'Elsewhere' blog

Tashkent, Toshkent Shahri, Uzbekistan
Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Returning to Tashkent after almost 4 weeks of new Central Asian experiences, we were ready for a new beginning. We had obtained a good measure of the geography of the region (the high mountain passes and valleys, rough roads and tunnels under construction), rewarding interactions with the various peoples and their culture and encounters with intrusive public officials. Now, we could begin another phase of exploration that would take us through the Silk Road cities of Uzbekistan.
 
Our Central Asian itinerary thus far may have seemed like a series of random accidental decisions but there was a method behind all that going back and forth. The primary factor that influenced it was the weather. It made sense to cover Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan (with their high mountainous regions) first before the onset of October. Tashkent offered the best air connection from India and so we had to start from there. So, the progression of Tashkent-Tajikistan-Kyrgyzstan-Kazakhstan may seem to be in the wrong direction (why go north when winter is approaching) in a latitudinal sense, it made perfect sense when viewed from the perspective of altitude. With October around the corner, and the mountains behind us, we can now look westward at the Kyzyl Sum desert and visit the famed, almost mythical, cities of the Silk Road in agreeable weather conditions. The desert had a reputation for being hot as late as September, so we hoped for cooler daytime temperatures in October without freezing up at night.
 
But first, we had one more visa to get in Tashkent. By this time, we had given up our plans for Turkmenistan due to the constraints imposed by their visa requirements. Once the decision was made, we could focus on planning for Azerbaijan. Despite a lot of research, it took a while for us to find the gate to the embassy, only to be told by the driver of the shiny BMW (which he was washing to maintain its good looks) with diplomatic plates that the Consul was not on the premises. The guard just shrugged his shoulders with a "What can I do?" expression. When the duo saw that we did not turn heel and disappear like they expected us to, they huddled together to look for a better approach to dealing with us. The driver dropped his hose and pulled out his mobile. The guard took our passports and a full quarter hour to enter our details into a register. The driver then indicated to us that the Consul was on his way. There was a convenient set of benches under a shelter just outside the embassy. The Consul arrived with his family in an identical shiny BMW and briefly nodded at us before going in. He did not seem upset at having been woken up at 10:30 in the morning on a Monday just because of a couple of drifters who did not seem to have gainful salaried employment. We were ushered into his office. We enjoyed the large map of Azerbaijan on the wall and we used it to memorize a few place names which we could use in our proposed itinerary. Our research had indicated that a lack of preparation could lead to puny 3 day visas. We really needed to make up a good story. We noticed that the book "Armenian Terror" was prominently displayed on the table where we were asked to fill out our forms. Our jaws collectively hit the floor on being told the cost of the visa and stayed there when it was doubled for "express" same day service. Standard service would take two weeks. At our urging, he said he could try and give us a 50% discount on the incremental portion of the "express" service but no more. After much good natured haggling, we decided to stick with the original "standard" service. Since we had not opted for "express", the earliest he could give us our visas was the next morning. Unlike the Kazakh embassy official in Bishkek, he was more than willing to endorse copies of our passports for use with the police. We had run out of copies and we had to ask him if he could kindly put his copier to use for our benefit? He nodded and with a straight face said "That would be another hundred and sixty dollars" and seemed satisfied at our reaction to this touch of humour.

Since we no longer planned to cross into Turkmenistan and had to get back to Tashkent (after our Silk Road trip) for our eventual air connection to Baku, we had two options for our Silk Road itinerary. Do the classic Tashkent-Samarqand-Bukhara-Khiva route in westward steps and return back to Tashkent or jump to Khiva and do it in reverse. Those who did it in reverse said that it made sense to start with Khiva (which was magnificent) and then go on to Bukhara (which was even more magnificent) and then to Samarqand (which was beyond belief). There were other views as well. We opted for the reverse route and lost no time in procuring train tickets from Tashkent to Urgench/Khiva at Tashkent's railway station. We noticed with interest that everyone at the ticket counter carried large bags of Uzbek Som and left with empty bags. Fortunately, the staff at the counter all had automatic currency counters.
 
We opted to stay in Tashkent's old town just north of bustling Chorsu Bazaar after our low key hotel experience the month before. We were treated to an enjoyable impromptu recital on the Dutar by the owner of our guesthouse, Mr. Murad Mirzo who happened to be a professor of history. This was an ancestral home going back to his grandfather with traditional fittings and a very nice courtyard. He played several tunes one after the other from memory, ranging from the Babur Nama to Omar Khayyam. He even sang the first two lines of a popular Mukesh song from the 1964 Hindi film Sangam,  rendering the emotion faithfully. His English was limited but he managed to convey a great passion for his family and the Uzbek people. Interestingly, he translated this identity to a Turkic one (the byline for his guesthouse was TurkTurizm) and bemoaned the loss of this identity due to the intervention of the Soviet era. The names of Timur and his descendant Babur came up (these two being independent Uzbekistan's iconic heroes) and led to Babur's India connection. He was startled and saddened when we told him that Indian history books held Akbar's name in greater regard than Babur's whose reign lasted a mere 4 years. He spoke of Babur's fondness for his homeland and how he wrote in Babur Nama about his regret in leaving it for foreign lands. 

Our host also narrated the story about Timur playing chess and just as he was engaged in swapping his king (Shah) for a rook, he got news of his son's birth and hence named him Shah Rukh. He (our host) became the second person on this trip to express a keen interest in making contact with an Indian movie star. But his intentions were different. He wanted to narrate this same story to Shah Rukh Khan and educate him on the provenance of his name. He pronounced the name like Shakh Rukh, unlike in India where the aspirated syllable in Shah is not rasped from the back of the throat. All over Central Asia, the name is pronounced with the double rasp. The Cyrillic letter for this throat destroying consonant is X. As in Shox Rux Xon. He was also quick to point out that the statue of Lal Bahadur Shastri ("Shastri sculpt" was how he put it) was right next door to his guest house. Our first knowledge of Tashkent was from this association with India's second Prime Minister who had died in 1966 in this city while still in office. We quickly popped around for a look at the smiling statue with the namaste-folded arms when a group of kids in the school nearby saw us and started shouting Namaste at us in excitement.
 
We got additional exposure to Timur and Babur (Timur's grandson's grandson) during our visit to the Museum of the History of the People of Uzbekistan. Apart from Timur and Babur, the personality of Ulughbek (grandson of Timur) and that of Alisher Navoi featured prominently in our explorations. We had encountered Alisher Navoi (15th Century) for the first time at the Tashkent Metro station that carries his name as well as interior artwork that features his life and works in bluish tiles. The familiar figures of Laila-Majnun, Farhad-Shirin (we had learnt enough Cyrillic to decipher them) were rendered on the walls of the Alisher Navoi station. Ulughbek was not just a ruler but also a famed scientist-astronomer whose name belongs with the likes of Tycho-Brahe and Copernicus. We resolved to enhance our knowledge of these historical figures and what better way to do it than during our visit to the cities where they lived and died?  How is it that Timur, whom the outside world regards as a mass murderer, is a great national hero in this country? And Babur's descendence from Timur and Chengiz Khan is considered a double badge of honor here, when in the outside world it would clear the room fast? Of course, Alisher Navoi's native Herat (in present day Afghanistan) was beyond the reach of our current trip, but Timur and Ulughbek's Samarqand was very much in our plans. 

A visit to the Tashkent Fine Arts Museum prepared us even further for our forthcoming trip. Paintings and embroidery associated with Samarqand, Bukhara and Khiva featured prominently. The museum did include a small display of foreign artifacts including an Indian section that featured the Veena (South Indian classical string instrument) and silk sarees. A few other countries were included as well.

The guesthouse was also a great place to meet other travelers and exchange notes. There were a couple of bicyclists (Roberto and Annika) who were on the road for several months exploring various cuisines and cultures. Lin (from China) was intent on getting to Afghanistan to view the Bamiyan Buddha remains after a fast transit through the Silk Road. We also met Ruvan, who we had previously seen in Karakol, Kyrgyzstan. A couple from the Nederlands were exploring Uzbekistan for its fabrics. Tamili (from Israel) had just returned from her Silk Road journey and shared her experiences with us which was useful in making our own plans.

Comments

The history lesson simply whets the appetite for what lays ahead. But all this seems to be from the Timur era. Isn't there fodness for the period before Genghis sacked all these cities. The days of the Khwarazm Shah and before when Samarqand and Bukhara were probably the greatest cities in the world ??? From Ramesh, on Oct 20, 2012 at 06:11AM
With nothing tangible left from the time of the Khorezm Empire, there is hardly a reference to it in either Samarqand or Bukahra. Museums in Khiva (which later became the Khorezm capital) cover some of that history, but the details in English were sketchy. Actually important Khorezm cities like Konye-Urgench and Merv are inside current day Turkmenistan, so unfortunately we were unable to visit. From Malini and Venkatesh, on Oct 21, 2012 at 07:01PM

Pictures & Video

Mr. Murad Mirzo playing the Dutar
Mr. Murad Mirzo playing the Dutar
Statue of Lal Bahadur Shastri in a Tashkent school
Statue of Lal Bahadur Shastri in a Tashkent school
History Museum of the People of Uzbekistan
History Museum of the People of Uzbekistan
Tashkent Railway Station
Tashkent Railway Station
Food section at Chorsu Market
Food section at Chorsu Market
Back to my 'Elsewhere' blog